Punch-Line Ads Score Big in Pro Football Birthplace Canton, Ohio

Survey Asked People In Bellwether City To Rate Best, Worst Super Bowl Commercials

Canton, Ohio (January 27, 2003)-Super Bowl television commercials with punch-line humor made the biggest impact in a survey designed to measure the opinions of viewers here in Canton, Ohio, the birthplace of professional football.

The on-line poll was conducted by Innis Maggiore Group, an advertising agency based here. This year's survey results followed trends established in previous years' polls in that humorous ads scored highest here. Survey respondents, again following a similar trend established in previous years, yawned over ads that took a relatively straight approach in delivering their messages or used humor in a way that failed to sink in with the respondents.

"A good laugh is like a special gift from the advertiser , it scores big with TV viewers here in middle America," said Innis Maggiore Group Creative Director Jeff Goldman. "This year, our bellwether audience in Canton told us Anheuser-Busch, Pepsi, FedEx and Reebok did that best of all."

Conversely, the ads that flopped used creative approaches that were not executed to the same degree of perfection as the winners' efforts, Goldman said.

"Our poll continues to show us that the best Super Bowl commercials are those that make people laugh out loud while they reinforce the advertisers' messages," Goldman said. "Of course, it would be inappropriate to do a funny ad about illegal drugs and terrorism. But that takes us to the question: Is it a good idea to tackle serious subjects during the Super Bowl? The message may be very important, but will the audience listen?"

Following are the best five Super Bowl ads, as rated by fans here in Canton:

  1. Anheuser-Busch's Budweiser "Clydesdales Replay”
  2. FedEx "Castaway"
  3. Pepsi Twist "Ozzie's Nightmare"
  4. Reebok "Terry Tate, Office Linebacker"
  5. Pepsi Sierra Mist "Fire Hydrant"

The worst five:

  1. Levi Strauss Type1 jeans
  2. Subway "Jared"
  3. Visa USA Check Card "Yao Ming"
  4. Monster.com "Driver on the loose"
  5. Pepsi Twist "Ozzie's Nightmare"

"Having a little fun with the state of today's NFL officiating struck a major chord with folks here in Canton," Goldman said. The Budweiser ad featured a zebra looking at a replay camera. "Everybody who watches any football understood the image immediately, unlike the Levi Strauss ad that I don't think anyone has figured out yet." In that ad, a man and woman in Levis faced a stampeding herd of bison. "I think our respondents felt lost on that one," Goldman said.

Goldman said it was interesting that the Pepsi Twist commercial featuring rocker Ozzie Osbourne made the "best" and "worst" lists.

"Despite his renewed popularity, Ozzie Osbourne's television show doesn't appeal to everyone. I think that here in Canton, people either love him or hate him," Goldman said.

Canton is an excellent choice for gauging the public's opinions about Super Bowl television ads for a number of reasons. It was one of the National Football League's original franchise cities and is the site of the Pro Football Hall of Fame. In addition, the city often is selected as a barometer of how heartland America stands on national trends and issues.

"We began our Canton survey three years ago because we thought other Americans would be interested in knowing how we rate the creative work displayed during the Super Bowl, the highest-profile advertising event of the year," said Dick Maggiore, president of Innis Maggiore Group. "People like the opportunity to let advertisers know first-hand whether their money was well spent. The ads themselves are the subject of Monday morning 'quarterbacking' as much as the game itself."

Co-sponsors of the survey this year were Atwood Lake Resort and Conference Center and Fishers Foods.

Innis Maggiore Group is an advertising and public relations firm with nearly 60 associates and offices in Canton and Youngstown, Ohio, and Pittsburgh, Pa. The company has tripled in size since 1997, with 2002 capitalized billings of more than $26 million. Key clients include Microsoft's MSN, Aultman Health Foundation, Brewster Dairy, Liquid Control Corp., Louisiana-Pacific Corp., Microsoft Corp., NancyLopezGolf, NEOUCOM, Nickles Bakery, Parker Hannifin, Progressive Foam Technologies, Rainbow Rentals, Republic Engineered Products, Smithers-Oasis Co., Square Two Golf and Waikem Auto Group. Innis Maggiore is a member of the American Association of Advertising Agencies, the Direct Marketing Association, the National Investor Relations Institute and the Public Relations Society of America.

For more information contact:

Jim Cyphert
Director of Public Relations
Innis Maggiore
P: 330-492-5500
Email: jim.cyphert@innismaggiore.com


PositionistView® is an inside look into Innis Maggiore's thinking, culture and talent. They're opinon pieces through the positioning filter. No jargon. No ad-speak babble.

March 8, 2022

In the third decade of the 21st century, GM may once again be a big brand in big trouble paying the high cost of brand positioning failure.

January 5, 2022

With a GDP of nearly $20 trillion and a citizenry accounting for more than a quarter of the global household consumption, the United States is inarguably the most hyper-consumer economy…

June 29, 2021

Advertisers have long been known for how well they accept change, pivot to new possibilities and adopt the newest technologies.

June 23, 2021

Many pundits in the world of marketing and advertising are obsessed with stuff dying. “Radio is dead in 10 years. This study proves it. ” “TV is dying.

April 7, 2021

Advertisers have long understood the potency of television (TV) as a brand-building medium for consumer products. However, business-to-business advertisers typically kept their distance, and for good reason.

Agency News

From associate promotions and new team members to awards and events, keep up with the growth and good things happening at Innis Maggiore.

May 23, 2022
CANTON, Ohio (May 23, 2022) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced it earned a 2022 Business Excellence Award presented by the Canton Regional Chamber of Commerce. The brand positioning agency was honored at a ceremony and dinner at the DoubleTree by Hilton Canton Downtown.
May 13, 2022
CANTON, Ohio (May 13, 2022) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced the promotions of four associates.
March 29, 2022
CANTON, Ohio (March 29, 2022) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced the promotions of Cheryl Henderson to creative director, Alicia Jordan to art and video director, Emily Mays to associate creative director, Rich Grisak to senior media analyst, Veronica Smith to senior media strategist, and…
January 18, 2022
CANTON, Ohio (Jan. 18, 2022) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced the addition of two new associates.
November 2, 2021
CANTON, Ohio (Nov. 2, 2021) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced the addition of two fall interns, one in the Digital Marketing department and one in its Creative department.