• Agency
  • Positioning
  • Clients
  • Services
  • Portfolio
  • Media
  • 330-492-5500
  • Contact Us
brand positioning blog positionistview innis maggiore revised
Scroll To Top

By Dick Maggiore and Mark Vandegrift

book dick
Download  

Dick Maggiore's Book The CEO's Number One Responsibility: Identifying and Articulating Your Brand's Position

book mark
Download  

Mark Vandegrift's Book Keyword: Positioning How Search Proves the Principles of Brand Positioning

Pros and Cons of the New Big Ten Logo

Grading the New Big Ten Logo

January 14, 2011   -   0 Comment   -   Jeff Monter

As the "resident expert" on logo design at the nation's leading agency in the practice of positioning, I was asked to provide a critique on the new Big Ten logo created by international design firm Pentagram. But first, I'd like to critique all the logo critics out there who seem to think: a) they're all master logo designers, b) logo design is easy, and c) even though they didn't pay for the new Big Ten logo, their opinions should persuade the organization to change it to match their ideas of the perfect look.

It's amazing how society is becoming more cynical, sarcastic, and mean-spirited, even toward things that really don't affect it. The recent rantings about the new Big Ten logo and other brand creative are good examples.

Most people have no idea about the process of logo design ... the client input, the parameters, how it will be used, committee approval processes, etc.

For instance, let's look at some of the possible parameters the designers had to consider for the new Big Ten logo:

    1. It must be general enough to represent every sport in every athletic department of all 12 schools.
    2. The new Big Ten logo must be simple, bold, and readable enough to be used in a multitude of applications ranging from a 50-foot banner to a ½-inch lapel pin.
    3. Committees from all 12 schools must approve it. (Good luck with that one!)

Not an easy task.

Now that I have that off my chest, let's move on to the things I like and dislike about the new Big Ten logo.

Likes:

    • The new Big Ten logo is definitely easy to read.
    • The heavy serif font is reminiscent of the legendary "letters" athletes sewed onto their school jackets. And since the two conferences within the league are being renamed, "Legends" and "Leaders," it fits the theme.
    • The "clever" creation of the number 10 depicted in the "I" and "G" in the word "BIG." (It's easy to see in the black and blue version.) I had to laugh when one critic asked why the designer used a lowercase "L" instead of a capital "I." It's actually a numeral "1." Someone should ask why she has a capital "L" on her forehead! (Oops, the sarcasm is contagious.)

Dislikes:

    • The baby blue color of the new Big Ten logo is weak for a powerhouse athletic organization.
    • The design firm didn't find a way to subtly incorporate the number of teams in the league. The old Big Ten logo snuck in the number 11 in the negative space — a very nice touch.
    • Although it fits all the parameters, it's just not very exciting. I think there could have been a way to add a little jazz without complicating it.

So, my final grade for the new Big Ten logo? I'd give it a C+.

By the way, check out the old Pac-10 logo for comparison. Gee, I wonder why they used a lowercase "a"?

Jeff Monter is Innis Maggiore's Principal Creative Services.

Posted in Digital Media and Marketing Tagged Branding , Positioning , Strategy, Differentiation , Logo , Big Ten

Previous Post
←  Watch Out for That New Media Advertising Magic Pixie Dust!
Next Post
2011 New Media Trends to Watch  →
» Innis Maggiore
Innis Maggiore Brand Positioning

Founded more than 50 years ago in Canton, Ohio, Innis Maggiore remains independently owned, and today is ranked in the top 10 percent of the nation's agencies.

© 2025 Innis Maggiore Group, Inc. | ph: 330.492.5500

Recent Posts
Wanna soggy donut?
0 Comments May 28, 2025
Marketing to AI
0 Comments April 29, 2025
Fasten your seatbelts. Southwest Airlines’ brand differentiation strategy hits turbulent times.
0 Comments April 8, 2025
Mastering Brand Recognition Strategy: Coca-Cola “Pops” Into the New Soda Craze
0 Comments March 25, 2025
Checklist for Choosing a Marketing Agency
0 Comments March 4, 2025
Categories
  • Brand Positioning
  • Business
  • Content Marketing
  • Digital Media and Marketing
  • Social Media
PositionistView®
VIEW ALL RSS

PositionistView® is an inside look into Innis Maggiore's thinking, culture, and talent. They're opinon pieces through the positioning filter. No jargon. No ad-speak babble.

Brand Partnership McDonalds Krispy Kreme - Innis Maggiore
May 28, 2025
Wanna soggy donut?

Because that’s the result of the brand partnership between McDonald’s and Krispy Kreme.

Marketing to AI Innis Maggiore
April 29, 2025
Marketing to AI

My brother texted me the above screen shot, and it made me ponder the question: Who is the arbiter of truth? Are we really turning this over to machines to…

Southwest Airlines brand differentiation strategy hits turbulent times
April 8, 2025
Fasten your seatbelts. Southwest Airlines’ brand differentiation strategy hits turbulent times.

Southwest Airlines was founded with a clear mission — to provide low-cost, convenient airfare for patrons.

Mastering Brand Recognition Strategy
March 25, 2025
Mastering Brand Recognition Strategy: Coca-Cola “Pops” Into the New Soda Craze

There’s Poppi, Popwell, Olipop, Culture Pop, and now Simply Pop.

Checklist for Choosing a Marketing Agency
March 4, 2025
Checklist for Choosing a Marketing Agency

When it comes to driving business growth, turning your attention to marketing stands out as one of the most important strategies to company success.

Agency News
VIEW ALL RSS

From associate promotions and new team members to awards and events, keep up with the growth and good things happening at Innis Maggiore.

Internship at Ad Agency - Innis Maggiore
June 10, 2025
Students Borland and Robson start summer internships at ad agency
CANTON, Ohio (June 10, 2025) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced that two students — Chase Borland and Megan Robson — have started summer internships at the ad agency.
Advertising Scholarship CAF 2025 - Innis Maggiore
June 3, 2025
Canton Ad Federation (CAF) awards 2025 advertising scholarship to Ripley Kemp
CANTON, Ohio (June 3, 2025) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced Ripley Kemp is the 2025 recipient of the Canton Ad Federation (CAF) scholarship. Kemp studies media with minors in psychology and film production at Ohio University.
Innis Maggiore Business Community Involvement
May 8, 2025
Innis Maggiore continues commitment to business community involvement
CANTON, Ohio (May 8, 2025) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced initiatives demonstrating its commitment to business community involvement.
garage door marketing agency Innis Maggiore
May 6, 2025
Leading garage door marketing agency Innis Maggiore hired by Wayne Door
CANTON, Ohio (May 6, 2025) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced it is handling digital marketing for Wayne Door and its sister company, Overhead Door Co. of Akron.
Service marketing agency Innis Maggiore awarded 10 SIAA Awards
March 17, 2025
Innis Maggiore awarded 10 Service Industry Advertising Awards (SIAA)
CANTON, Ohio (March 17, 2025) — Innis Maggiore, the nation’s leading positioning ad agency, today announced that it earned 10 Service Industry Advertising Awards (SIAA) for ReliaRide Medical Transportation and Stark Area Regional Transit Authority (SARTA). The agency was among only 10% of entries recognized.
Innis Maggiore Brand Positioning

Founded more than 50 years ago in Canton, Ohio, Innis Maggiore remains independently owned, and today is ranked in the top 10 percent of the nation's agencies.

Careers Media Contact Privacy Policy

© 2025 Innis Maggiore Group, Inc. | ph: 330.492.5500